When the Tar Heels left Coral Gables last February 9 as victims of a violent Miami beatdown, an NCAA Tournament bid was far from a certainty. NIT discussion had grown ever-real for one of college basketball’s flagship programs, and the aimless Heels headed north still seeking an identity. Enter P.J. Hairston. Roy Williams inserted his sixth man into the starting lineup four days later, playing the 6’5” Hairston as a de facto power forward in a small-ball lineup. The new look Heels would lose a tight one to Duke in Cameron that night, but they went on to win eight of their last 10 contests, comfortably earning an NCAA Tournament bid in the process. That lineup undoubtedly assisted in creating an identity on the court for UNC, but it’s no reach to say that P.J. Hairston was the key to salvaging the Carolina season.
Oh, what a difference an offseason can make. The headlines have come fast and furious all summer: a speeding ticket, an arrest for marijuana and gun possession, reckless driving, illegal benefits in the form of a rental car. All were transgressions attached to Hairston in the past six months, which has left his eligibility in a case of serious limbo right now. While we hope Hairston can get everything together for his own sake, it also leaves Roy Williams’ bunch in a tricky predicament heading into this season. We don’t know when (or if) Hairston will be back; will the man who saved the Heels’ season a year ago be needed to avoid disappointment this time around?
It’s pretty obvious that UNC will be a worse team without Hairston on the court. Not only did his insertion into the starting lineup set off that impressive end of year run, but his production was phenomenal throughout the year. He made 49 percent of his two-point field goals, 40 percent of three-point attempts, and 78 percent from the free throw line — shooting splits that helped give birth to an Offensive rating of 120.3, the 63rd best total in the nation. The most surprising element of efficiency in Hairston’s game last season, given his erratic reputation on (and now off) the court, was a minuscule turnover rate of 10.7 percent. It’s a metric that catch-and-shoot players (who rarely have to handle the ball) often shine in, and while Hairston does his fair share of spotting up, his dribble-drive game is used often enough for this percentage to really impress. Hairston may not always be the most willing defender (despite having all the necessary tools), but there really is no weakness in his offensive game.
So P.J. Hairston is a lethal offensive weapon, we get that. But will his potential absence really matter in the overall scope of the Carolina campaign? The answer just has to be yes. This Tar Heel team likely has a better worst-case scenario than the younger version a year ago, so no Hairston shouldn’t mean an automatic relegation to the NIT, or really anything close. Leaps from James Michael McAdoo and Marcus Paige would soften the blow of any lengthy Hairston suspension, but neither of those players possesses the offensive explosiveness that Hairston does. His impact on last season’s team was profound; with a similar nucleus in place this go-around, and little in the way of contributions from newcomers expected, it’s hard to believe he wouldn’t maintain the same significant value he did a year ago.
Nobody is calling Carolina a true title contender entering the year, but as the 12th ranked team in the nation (via the AP poll), UNC also can’t be considered to be too far off. Even without Hairston, there is enough talent, both on the court and sidelines, to hang around the ACC race for a while and win a game or two in the Big Dance. But if the Heels are to become a true March threat, the kind of team that will strike terror into any opponent, they will need the always-attacking Hairston in the fold. His brash fearlessness got him, and UNC, into this mess, but that same trait may end up being the key to any serious Carolina March aspirations.